When ponies began to run rampant on 4chan, they mainly concentrated in two areas: the pony threads on /co/ and /b/. In late January, 2011, users from the pony threads on /b/ were banned one after another in a mod attempt to rid /b/ of ponies. As a result, a user by the name of Orange Blaze founded Ponychan as a haven for these users. This event became known as the First Great Pony Purge. The /co/ threads also founded their own chan, FiMchan. While both pony boards, the two chans had very little in common. To this day, many FiMchanners regard Ponychan with distaste. The reason for this is the very different ideals each chan was founded on. While FiMchan decided to stay nearly the same as the 4chan threads, Ponychan wanted to be completely different from 4chan. The staff of Ponychan would remove anything even resembling 4chan culture in an attempt to let Ponychan form its own culture. These attempts were successful and Ponychan still manages to be vastly different from 4chan even today.
Early DaysEditThe early days of Ponychan are regarded with nostalgia by most users. Even users on offshoot chans such as Stevenchan, GETchan, efchan, and MLPchan remember these times fondly. They are remembered as a time of peace. The generally accepted time frame for Ponychan's early days is from its inception to 11 July, 2011. The first big event to occur during this time was the splitting of /pony/ and /oat/. Originally they were solely one board, /pony/, the pony discussion board. However, the admin wanted a board for serious discussion and a board for off-topic discussion. Thus he split the two. GETchan's origins stem from this split. The first GET Thread was made on 19 April, 2011, the same day that /pony/ was split. The original thread was a GET thread about the split itself. This led many GET-loving users to come together and form their own threads. The GET Threads became a serial thread on 14 May, 2011.
The next big event was the /lol/-/test/ War. A secret board for users to hang out with the mods called /lol/ was made. A select few users were chosen to post on the board. These users were known as /lol/is. Meanwhile, word of the board got out to a group of individuals who claimed /test/ as their base of operations, though the name of the board was unknown to them. They called themselves /test/es. This led to a search for the board, though it was largely unsuccessful. /lol/ then raided /test/ with zebras on 24 May, 2011 while referring to themsalves as "the Forsaken". The following day, the /test/es managed to figure out the name of the board. They were far too late, however, for the /lol/is had discovered a new secret board and made it their base of operations, /chandroidtest/.
Before the /test/es could make their next move, however, the admin intervened in the fight and decided to delete both /lol/ and /chandroidtest/, as well as force the /test/es out of /test/. The /lol/is were given a time limit of half an hour before their boards were deleted. At this moment, both /lol/is and /test/es came together to bid farewell to their boards. It was a time of harmony between fighting and the inevitable demise. The two groups then proceeded to integrate back into the Ponychan userbase and came across each other a few times, each time peacefully.
Disagreements and splitsEditThe end of Ponychan's early days were marked with much fighting between users, including the staff itself. A controversial event concerning the admin's methods of moderation occurred on 11 July, 2011, causing multiple mods and users to leave the chan for good. Three days later, Lunachan was founded as a bunker for those that did not want to get caught up in these disagreements. It soon found itself getting much use. Frequent bouts between the staff and users began to occur over the idea of Ponychan being founded on the idea of "love and tolerance". The phrase originated from the /b/ pony threads, constantly used to sarcastically reply to trolls. Orange wanted to apply the idea of real love and tolerance to his chan, however. As a result, the community that formed was quite different to the 4chan's community.
Users argued that the idea of love and tolerance was only a façade to lure them into a false sense of security while mod activity remained secret. The staff argued that the idea of love and tolerance was the ground on which Ponychan was built, therefore being a key factor in making Ponychan so different from other chans. The hostility temporarily eased with an influx of posters from 4chan's /b/, but conflicts soon began to arise again. At the same time, tension began to grow between the GET threads and the rest of the chan. Eventually, the GETters founded their own chan on 6 November, 2011. However, the conflict did not end until the 13 November. The staff then considered the users' demands and on 12 January, 2012, /ef/ was created. It was meant to serve as a board with more lax rules and a more 4chan-like approach. The board was eventually deemed a failure and scrapped. Many users, feeling this was unjustified, set out to build their own chan, efchan.
Bad blood only continued to flow between the staff and the users. A group of RPers disagreed with Orange's moderation and they were banned. They went on to found Equestriachan. A substantial portion of the board began to demand changes in moderation. Refusing to negotiate any longer, the staff only ignored these demands. On 13 July, 2012, these users founded MLPchan. As a result, Ponychan lost a substansial amount of its userbase. Soon a change in adminship took place, as Orange took an indefinite leave. The chan changed greatly during this time, as users found themselves surrounded by a completely different form of moderation. The image of love and tolerance slowly shattered and the users discovered the cultures of other chans. Soon people were able to say "faggot" without an extreme reaction from the userbase.
On 24 January, 2015, talks began between the staffs of MLPchan and Ponychan to discuss the idea of a potential merger. Eventually it was agreed that MLPchan would merge into Ponychan and the Ponychan name would be retained, while adopting various aspects from MLPchan, including the Tinyboard software, the /anon/ board, and part of the MLPchan staff. The merger was completed exactly three months later on 24 April, 2015, and MLPchan ceased to exist as a separate entity.